Deficit theory: In 1975, Robin Lakoff published a theory
based around the common phrases that make women’s language so distinctively different.
She made the statements that are more polite in the way they address people for
example: “Would you mind …” or “I’d appreciate it” in comparison to men who are
usually more abrupt in and less polite. Lakoff examined women’s use of tag
questions and politeness to come to the conclusion that when women use this
language, they are showing signs of uncertainty and making themselves seem to
have inferior status. Another theorist
who studied deficit language features was Jespersen. Jespersen defined male
language as the standard whilst women’s language was seen as deficient. This
theory brought up a lot of division between men and women as this theory
brought up ideas that women’s language was inherently ‘wrong’ and or had
something that made it use men’s language
as a sort of ‘benchmark’
These techniques identified in the deficit theory could be
used in real life texts for example, advertisements for food produce where a
little girl asks her mother politely for something to eat and the little boy
asks in a less polite manner yet receives his first as the polite manner showed
an inferior side and therefore lead the boy to get his way first as the
stereotype that men have a more intimidating language and tone than women was
made clear in this advertisement.
I looked at a female advice column from ELLE magazine and I began
to notice the polite language the women in need were using to ask for advice
without sounding like they’re hassling the columnist. I looked at a male advice
column called ‘Ask the Dad’ which is mainly a column based around males who
need advice with the occasional polite female cry for help. I began to see that
the column from ELLE magazine began with the advice seeker’s question which
began by quickly addressing the problem. “How can I stop people from constantly
interrupting me?”